Five Star Gift Ideas

How about a mystery novel? You could get her one of the classics like the Agatha Christie book "Murder on the Orient Express" or a more recent bestseller like "Gone Girl" by Gillian Flynn. Alternatively, you could get her a mystery-themed board game like "Clue" or "Mysterium" for a fun and interactive date night. Another option could be to plan a surprise mystery date and take her on a tour of a nearby city that has a lot of quirky mysteries and secret spots.

Or you can get her a star map with the date of your first kiss.

Mandy Shepherd says about Under Lucky Stars star maps:

“I ordered my wife a star map for Valentine's day and it was lost in the mail , I emailed under the lucky star and they immediately took care of and I received it a few days later exactly the way I ordered it... totally recommend”